Dear Vancouver, Please Don't Boo Our National Anthem
That the Vancouver Canucks and the Boston Bruins will meet in the Stanley Cup Finals tonight is very fitting. I recently watched the run of "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip" on Netflix (great acting, surprisingly bad writing) and it was Bradley Whitford's Danny that didn't want to film a movie in Vancouver. "We’re not shooting in Vancouver. I’m drawing the line on the insanity. Vancouver doesn’t look like anything. It doesn’t even look like Vancouver. It looks like Boston, California." That was maybe the one laugh-out-loud line for this former New Englander. It's nice to think that Boston has a West Coast Canadian Dopplegänger. The Vancouver Canucks have not won the Stanley Cup in all of their 40 years of existence. Which include some of the most awesome uniforms in the history of all sports. My Boston Bruins have not won in my lifetime. They last won a Stanley Cup eight months before I was born. In the early '70s, Boston was a hockey town and Bobby Orr was its overlord. But I come not to write about hockey, today. I come to write about National Anthems.
Rene Rancourt is a Boston Garden Legend. Age Unknown, he has been singing the American and the Canadian National Anthems before Bruins games for 35 years. He is, quite frankly, The Man. In 2004, the Bruins' rivalry with the Montreal Canadians mixed in with politics in the first round of the playoffs. Montreal fans brutally booed the U.S. National Anthem during the first two games of the First Round of the Playoffs. In response, the Boston fans stood and cheered and knocked together those horrible thundersticks during Rancourt's stirring version of the Canadian National Anthem. I'm telling you, Rene Rancourt makes grown men cry with his Anthem singing. You may have heard the song a million times, but that dude bangs it out. I'm a much bigger fan of the Canadian National Anthem than the American National Anthem. I'm hoping at some point the U.S. could have an American Idol-like show in which we try to write a better National Anthem and everyone gets to vote. "American Anthem?" Janet Jones Gretzky could be a judge for symmetry's sake.
Anyway, the 2004 cheering of the Canadian National Anthem is a golden moment of class for a New England Fan Base that has kind of a bad reputation in the class department. But maybe unfairly. I was there the day Fenway Park gave Yankees manager Joe Torre a standing ovation on his first game back after cancer treatment. And I was there the day Charles Barkley grabbed a microphone and addressed the Boston Garden crowd to a standing ovation at the halftime of a Celtics/Rockets game one day after his career-ending injury. Fenway gave a standing O to DiMaggio during his last appearance, and they will do the same for Derek Jeter. Perhaps we pick our moments when it comes to class. Or, given the time to think about how we want to respond, our better, smarter angels are victorious.
The Canadian National Anthem is just frankly an awesome song. I wish it was played before all NHL hockey games. If I were in charge of the league there would be an even amount of Canadian and American teams and those would be the two conferences. I'd keep both New York teams (move the Islanders to Brooklyn, for my own personal convienence), Boston, Chicago, Buffalo, Washington, Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Minnesota, New Jersey, Detroit, Dallas (they have a huge fanbase, what are you gonna do?), St. Louis, L.A., maybe move a team to Hartford, Anchorage or Milwaukee. Then add in a bunch of Canadian teams in Regina, British Columbia, Quebec, Saskatchewan, Hamilton, etc. Have a Canadian conference and an American conference. You can't tell me that regular season game between Quebec and Hamilton wouldn't be a barnburner. Or that, when the Toronto Maple Leafs came to your Canadian Town you wouldn't want to be at that game. Hockey is Canada's game. We're just borrowing it here.
Under that scenario, a U.S. team would always be playing a Canadian team for the Stanley Cup. The All-Star game would always be Canada v. U.S. And, if the Vancouver Gold Medal Hockey Game was any example, everyone would be happy and would probably watch. There is a healthy, awesome rivalry between the U.S. and Canada in hockey that transferred over to the ice during that Gold Medal Game. It was not just the best hockey game many of us had seen in decades, it was the most watched in, like, ever.
One drawback to the rivalry has been the booing of the American National Anthem. Maybe more understandable in 2004, when the U.S. was invading countries for no reason. I mean, we're still there, but we're trying to get out. Leaving is the hardest part, as Senator Tom Petty once sang. It may just be a Montreal thing. I don't remember if Ottawa or Edmonton booed the National Anthem during their recent Stanley Cup Finals. And, yeah, I get it. America sucks. We're the big boisterous polluting nation to your South where the sun actually comes out once in a while and Summer isn't just a week in July. All of Canada's most talented folks usually move down here and become U.S. citizens to become even bigger stars. But you guys have health care and that pronouncing "about" thing. So I'd say it's a wash. We should be Abbot and Costello, Batman and Robin. But the truth is, Robin secretly hates Batman. We saw that with Scottie Pippin's recent blasphemer statements about how Michael Jordan maybe isn't the greatest basketball player of all time. Even if he's not, Pippin should say he is. Without Michael Jordan, Scottie Pippin would be just another good basketball player with no championship rings. A less funny Charles Barkley. So I get why Canadians might hate Americans. We're such jackasses, it's true.
But that's no reason to boo our National Anthem. I'd like to think I live in a world where Canadians react to things Better Than Americans Would. Canadians are nicer than us. You don't invade countries; and when I was abroad in the Czech Republic, I frequently pretended to be Canadian so I wouldn't have to talk about American foreign policy. Which is generally asinine. If I was the President, my foreign policy would be directed by Noam Chomsky. Just whatever he wants, that's fine. Let him be our moral compass for a while.
I don't get why Canadians boo our National Anthem publicly at big hockey games. You can whistle all you want during it, we don't really get that whistling thing. Americans don't hear whistling as booing. We just think it's wolf whistle cheering. So, that's fine. But booing is booing. Have you ever heard boos? They are amazingly cutting. What a sound! It is no fun to be booed. I personally like being booed during poetry readings more than I like Poetry Applause. I have a complicated relationship with applause. Laughter I like. Applause? Eh. Booing I love! But, in general, booing is terrifying. And being booed by Canadians is even more jarring. It's one thing if you're booed in Philadelphia or Chicago. That's like being greeted warmly. Canadians booing? That's like being spit on by an angel. Or having a unicorn take a crap on your chest while you're sleeping.
Can we skip that part of the Stanley Cup Finals this year? Hockey is the one sport in which an award is given for Sportsmanship. And that the series doesn't end until all the players on both teams have shaken hands. I'd like to think that that's the Canadian influence. I wish baseball players would greet each other with handshakes before games. And American football players would all bow in prayer together for their safety before kick-offs. In soccer, they shake hands before all games. But it's easier to be charitable and sportsman-like before a game. It's quite another thing to line up and congratulate the people who just beat you. That's real sportsmanship, and that is one of the truly great things about hockey. We love our games because they teach us something about ourselves, about who we really are when all the pressure is on. Those who act with grace and humanity in such moments deserve our profound respect. In hockey, the National Anthems set the tone for the game.
No doubt, the Stanley Cup Finals will be heated affairs. Let's all set a tone of sportsmanship and civility to begin them. I honestly will be happy for Vancouver if they win the Stanley Cup over the Bruins. If the Bruins win, I will be experiencing feelings I haven't felt since 2004 or 2002. The Celtics always win, so their victories in my lifetime simply confirmed our birthright as fans. But if the Bruins end up victorious, I will be witnessing something I never thought I'd see in my lifetime. The Stanley Cup is the greatest trophy in all of sports. And to see it lifted up by my Bruins is unthinkable. I want to sip chowder from the Stanley Cup. That's what I'd rather be thinking about during these Finals. Not Booing. Booing begets stories about booing (like this one I guess). But, if you're reading this, there is still time for Vancouver to take the high road. Let's enjoy hockey! And save the booing for the actual game.
Jim Behrle tweets at @behrle for your possible amusement.
Photo by Dan4th, from Flickr.






You mean to tell me "God Bless America" is not our national anthem? I need to get out of Philadelphia and post 9/11 America more often.
This is how Canadians sing the national anthem.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meLpuF9UMvk
But both the NBA and MLB have sportsmanship awards? And in football all of the players and coaches come out and shake hands after games?
@soco Lady Bing just seems to have more cache.
@Jim Behrle@twitter maybe the MLB and NBA should publicize their awards better.
@Jim Behrle@twitter The handshake after the game is reason #752 why hockey is such a great game.
This might be the best, most nuanced piece about hockey I've ever read on the internet. But I don't think Vancouver will boo during the National Anthem, the city is much more chill. Montreal riots after regular season home wins, after all.
The fans in Vancouver are CLASSY. You most likely will not hear booing from your true Canucks fan. I'm a Canucks fan from Seattle and during the games I've attended and watched over the many years I've never heard booing from them. I proudly sang my country's national anthem in Vancouver and sang along with the Canadians singing Oh Canada.
BTW-Mark Donnelly is THE MAN.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mkmPh2gIJOU
@Kurt Klatt@facebook I don't know, when you guys play my Blackhawks I've noticed some less than classy fan antics. But maybe that'll change now that you finally won a playoff series against us.
Wait, Jim Behrle gives poetry readings?
Go Canucks.
In Buffalo both the US and Canadian anthems are played prior to every Sabres game regardless of whether they are playing a Canadian team. It's nice.
@frontsidebus I always assumed it was in tribute to all the SUNY students crossing the border to take advantage of the lower drinking age.
Rene Rancourt is indeed awesome, but I wouldn't bet on Bruins fans behaving themselves. Mostly because everyone in the Boston area seems to have lost their damn minds.
First, Go Canucks Go. Second, I really want to snark on this with a little jab, like "Isn't this rich, an American asking people to respect their country's anthem, what with its citizens all being paragons of respect and humility."
But actually you're totally right and booing the US national anthem is disgusting and so totally un-Canadian it isn't even funny. (Also, as Canadians love to point out when it suits them, the US teams are comprised in large part of Canadian players, sooo if you are booing their team's country aren't you kinda booing them and isn't that gross?) For what it's worth, I've never met or known anybody who would dare to boo another country's anthem, and the first time I heard it happen I was sick to my stomach with shame.
Anyway, I really don't think it'll happen in Vancouver and it DEFINITELY did not happen during my beloved Oilers cup run or Ottawa's run or even gross Calgary's run, for that matter, and also, Montrealers are crazy and barely Canadian. Ha ha. I'm joking, French Canadians. I love you and you are very Canadian. But we both know you're crazy, espesh where hockey is concerned.
Go Canucks Go.
Go Canucks.
@jaimeleigh
S'IL VOUS PLAIT
@jaimeleigh
Sorry, but any Oilers fan cheering for the Canucks is just plain wrong.
Go Bruins Go.
@en vague Probably, but I can't help but get excited for any Canadian team with a shot at the cup. I even (reluctantly and quietly) rooted for the Flames during their run. The only team I could never get behind is the leafs. Also, a good friend from my hometown played/plays for the Canucks, so I started liking them in the last few years. Go Canucks! Bring the cup home!!
The waiting is the hardest part. The waiting, not the leaving.
@KristaJulieva I meant the waiting for us to leave
@KristaJulieva Pretty sure it's the baiting.
Secretary of State Noam Chomsky. That would be awesomely ironic.
@whizzard Am I allowed to say I hate that old gasbag here? I don't live in Brooklyn or S.F., but I might want to visit again and I don't want my papers revoked.
@freetzy You're allowed to harsh peoples' mellows anywhere.
It's been mentioned, but Vancouver is not Montreal by any means. I was downtown and bespangled for the first USA-Canada game, and the worst trash talk I got was, "Miller is an excellent goalie." You're right though, the tribalism of the various fanbases may be my least favorite part of modern hockey. The antidote for me this season was 24/7. As a Flyer fan, it was almost dangerously humanizing (Matt Cooke's a good father! Maybe that will change when his kids reach elbow height).
I have to be pro-Bruin, only because I lived in Denver during Ray Bourque's last season and his final quest for the Cup. It was an incredible run and when the Avalanche won the whole thing, I remember thinking how wonderful the Bruins fans were at that time….they were really rooting for the Avs because they knew how much it meant to Bourque, after 22 years.
I'm sure it will be much the same for Cleveland fans, watching LeBron win with Miami. (ha. no.)
@hockeymom I don't even know you any more!
@Clarence Rosario Does it make it any better that when the Cup came to Denver, we were able to place our baby daughter in it and take a picture? (ensuring that she would never win a Stanley Cup herself, because she touched it before winning it. And also because she's a girl.)
@hockeymom OK, even as a Red Wings fan, I have to say that is awesome.
' I don't remember if Ottawa or Edmonton booed the National Anthem during their recent Stanley Cup Finals.'
No. It was the other way around. The San Jose Sharks fans booed the Canadian anthem during the Edmonton Oilers 06' cup run.
Vancouver won't boo. They don't even start cheering until they make the finals.
They just added Winnipeg. More teams to come. You deregulated your banks. Our dollar is higher.
Let's not forget. The U.S. Marines came out with the Canadian flag upside down pre-game, before the Blue Jays were possibly about to, and did, win the World Series for the first time.
That's a slap in the face.
@johnnyringo So what's the score? Canada 7, USA -∞
Facts 7, Score 3
Haha gotta love hockey fans
This is a non-issue, actually. As others have pointed out, we Vancouver fans just don't play that way, Behrle. It's just tacky, and we're kind of into good manners here (way more so than our sometimes brusque Montreal cousins). We often stand and sing our anthem even watching it on TV in the bar (I always do at home too), and at least where I watch it, we make sure people remove their hats for both anthems. After last night's exquisite win, the streets were predictably mental, but it was all good vibes. We shouted at a guy across the street in a Bruins jersey, but only to say "sorry!" and tell him what a good game his guys played. Montreal is about as different from Vancouver as you can get and still be part of the same land mass, so this is a really forced comparison, but I'm glad the point of the article is that you want us to win, because it is our year and this shit is totally happening. The Stanley Cup is finally coming home to Lord Stanley's park where it belongs.
Also, it really wasn't that long ago that American arenas would "accidentally" fly the Canadian flag upside down or get someone to sing our national anthem who didn't have a clue how it went. That's a wayyy bigger insult than a few jackass fans booing. And yes, Americans booed our anthem too. A lot. But it just galvanized us to win, and that's what we're going to do. Go Canucks! (PS: Hi Alex and Choire! Hockey makes a Hez all commenty again!)
I was at the game last night & after reading this excellent post, I actually sang along to the American national anthem. I was born in Vancouver, but remember watching Kate Smith sing "God Bless America" with my dearly departed Grandma who was from North Dakota and how deeply connected she was with her American roots. I got some strange stares from a few fans around me- but I sang even louder for "O Canada" along with Mark Donnelly & all was OK. I am very proud, lucky & blessed to be a North American! Since we're neighbours- it's all aboot being friends. Thanks for the great article.
Montrealers are a little crazier about their hockey, sure, but I can almost guarantee that the booing was more to do with the long, infamously intense rivalry between Boston and Montreal (and the hilarious and sometimes violent tension between their fans) than with the general attitude of Montrealers toward Americans and America. It doesn't excuse the act but may explain it a little better.
We're all just music critics. The fact is, your national anthem is a fucking musical travesty.
Sorry.
Also, as someone who's lived in Vancouver since 1981, I can absolutely swear that Vancouverites don't care about ANYTHING enough to really boo it.
I sat through the world premiere of Starwhackers, and only one woman had the balls to boo. Starwhackers. We are too fucking polite for our own good.
http://raincoaster.com/2011/04/28/starwhackers-the-liveblog/
I've often been told by Vancouver fans that Richard Loney, who frequently sings the American anthem, is a "national treasure". Yet the guy gallops through the Star-Spangled Banner like his pants are on fire and he can't wait to go put them out. Mark Donnelly, Vancouver's primary singer (and singer of their own anthem), does a great job although still at a faster clip than the song is meant to be sung. I've stood in Rogers Arena for a game, and watched various Canadian sports on TV, and honestly, few things are more moving than having 18,000 people singing the anthem together; it's beautiful.
I wish more American stadiums did that, because our anthem is very powerful, too. Look – as Americans, we GET it that our anthem isn't easy to sing. The melody is some 200 years old, so we didn't exactly have a choice about it. We also understand it gets into octaves that your average Joe Smith has a hard time singing.
I've been to a lot of arenas around the league, at least on the U.S. side of the border. The Canadian anthem always gets treated with respect down here. Hey, we get it if you don't agree with our country's national policies or actions, but those of us at sporting events don't have anything to do with those. We sing for pride (or in Chicago's case, cheer with pride), just as Canadians do.
Hockey is about sportsmanship – and while the Canucks haven't exactly been racking up sportsman-like conduct these playoffs – one way to show it is to respect the anthems. BOTH anthems, on both sides of the border.
Baseball has an award for sportsmen ship as well Jim
sportsmanship* :)
i am from the vancouver area i sure the heck hope we don't boo the u.s national anthem it is so unclassy does not matter what the issues that may divide us at the time i remember when the fans at yankee stadium booed the the canadian anthem in the early 1990's at a blue jays yankees series i was quite mad so i put my actions where my mouth says and i remember how that felt so canucks fans don't booo the u.s national anthem its a big sign of disrepect cause i know there a lot of good hearted american friends out there
I can absolutely swear that Vancouverites don't care about ANYTHING enough to really boo it.