Wednesday, July 20th, 2011
25

A Brief History of the Editorial Page of the 'New York Observer'

Today, the whole world, pretty much, is making fun of the New York Observer's editorial defending Rupert Murdoch. (It is pretty funny and ridiculous. But you know, it's tricky! The majority owner of the Observer has spent a good deal of time on Rupert Murdoch's boat, at least since his wedding, when he became more attractive socially, and honestly, instead of being a conflict of interest, I look at this as an informed viewpoint. That's what publishers are for!) But, for those just getting their first exposure, the Observer's editorial page has always been wildly wonky and fun. I mean, the other week we got an editorial headlined "PEDESTRIANS BEWARE," about allowing bikes in Central Park. "Cycling enthusiasts on the Upper West Side are delighted. The older, more-traditional residents of the Upper East Side are angry and frightened." Ha ha! Yes, those more-traditional bikeless residents of the Upper East Side. Oh, ARTHUR CARTER, MINORITY OBSERVER OWNER, YOU OLD SCOUNDREL. (Or… Joe Conason? Is that you?) But the page gets so much better. It's way funner than that new house of bloated horrors, Bloomberg View!

Here's from one of my other recent favorites:

If Memorial Day marks the unofficial start of summer, Independence Day is the unofficial start of the summer vacation season. With the school year over at last, families are getting ready for their long-planned holidays. Other New Yorkers are fleeing to the Hamptons, Cape Cod or the Jersey Shore for weekend respites from the city’s stale air and oppressive humidity.

The city will not, of course, be vacant come August.

IT WON'T? ARE YOU SURE? How would we ever know?

Then it goes on about how we should be nice to tourists!

Still, the page is way more sane than it used to be, at least when it's not cheerleading grossly for charter schools. A few years back, there was a long outraged editorial about the Puerto Rican parade and how the City needed to be saved from this menace. No joke: "For the past several years, the parade has been an embarrassment to New York, transforming Fifth Avenue and Central Park into a slovenly garbage heap." My goodness.

This ran at the bottom of the page, under an editorial describing the firing of Howell Raines as "one of the larger mistakes in The Times’ history." GOOD STUFF. There's so much more! But really: we must celebrate this beloved institution and its unique viewpoint!

(OH PS: Here's a great one I forgot! "It is clear now that we have made a terrible mistake, for Hillary Rodham Clinton is unfit for elective office. Had she any shame, she would resign. If federal officeholders were subject to popular recall, she'd be thrown out of office by springtime, the season of renewal." Love it!)

25 Comments / Post A Comment

jfruh (#713)

"…improved the readability of properties like The Wall Street Journal." So many big intimidating words, banished forever! (Or did he tweak the font or something?)

boyofdestiny (#1,243)

@jfruh Rupert Murdoch is a visionary in kerning.

David Roth (#4,429)

My mind was blown in a major way by this one, and I have the Twitter timeline (and more-or-less-just-me #InDefenseOfRupert hashtag) to prove it. But I had no idea that this was of a piece, because who even knew the Observer had editorials? I guess it's good to know and see how everyone at Le Cirque (or wherever) is talking about the news of the day, but it is also very nauseating (for me, at least) to know and see how everyone at Le Cirque is talking about etc etc.

barnhouse (#1,326)

+one zillion

jolie (#16)

You know what? NO. THE TOURISTS SHOULD BE NICE TO US. They's some rude motherfuckers.

saythatscool (#101)

@jolie You're absolutely right, Jolie. After all, every touring New Yorker I have ever met abroad is a portrait of civility and decorum. They should give lessons to us provincials so we stop embarrassing ourselves.

jolie (#16)

@saythatscool PREACH IT MY BROTHER

saythatscool (#101)

@jolie I HAVE VERY FIRM CONVICTIONS WHICH I ENJOY SHARING WITH OTHERS ON THE INTERNET. DON'T MOCK ME.

jolie (#16)

@saythatscool I'M RUBBER AND YOU'RE ET CETERA

saythatscool (#101)

@jolie But seriously, should I start douching with bleach?

jolie (#16)

@saythatscool I would suggest white vinegar, but only on the days when you're working the pole.

C_Webb (#855)

@saythatscool Only if you have clafoutis.

saythatscool (#101)

@C_Webb Leave my Greek maid out of this.

boyofdestiny (#1,243)

"The family’s attorney said that Mr. Murdoch put his head in his hands as he expressed his grief. What more could he have done?"

Rhetorical questions that are begging not to be taken rhetorically.

keisertroll (#1,117)

@boyofdestiny Leaping from life to life, putting things right that once went wrong, and hoping each time that his next leap will be the leap home?

boyofdestiny (#1,243)

@keisertroll Or he could go the route of another Murdock. If you have a problem, if no one else can help, and if you can find him, maybe you can hire Rupert Murdoch.

JoshUng (#11,371)

While I agree that I don't think Murdoch was actively telling NotW to hack into phones, or even really paid attention to what was happening, I think there is way to say that in an editorial that isn't basically a hand-job in print.

HiredGoons (#603)

HG's Guide On How To Treat Tourists:

- asking for site of historical note, museum, gallery, or general directions: charming, polite, and helpful.

- asking for directions to M&M Fat Farm, Juicy Couture or the American Girl Store: piss on hushpuppies.

Have I mentioned I'm an elitist lately?

C_Webb (#855)

@HiredGoons I tend to mishear "American Girl Store" as "Museum of Sex." I should really see a doctor about that.

hockeymom (#143)

@HiredGoons But what if I really, really want to see Cats?

JoshUng (#11,371)

@HiredGoons Maybe they came all the way from Wisconsin just to buy a pair of jeans from American Eagle.

"But its the NYC AMERICAN EAGLE!!!"

HiredGoons (#603)

@JoshUng: We traveled six hundred miles to go to the Gap!

HiredGoons (#603)

@C_Webb: If I *really* like them, they'll end up at a chicken slaughterhouse in Bushwick.

I got schkieved off of the Observer when I saw that Spiers was friends with Dana Vachon. Ech.

On a more serious note, the Observer has been "Murdochized" under the ownership of the real estate developer who owns it now, staking out one reactionary position or another. It used to be a pretty decent paper under Arthur Carter, but now it is just the carriage trade version of the NY Post.

Post a Comment