"Transformers: Dark of the Moon"
Perhaps you know him best as the whimpery gay dude in rehab in the bizarre Sandra Bullock vehicle 28 Days? Perhaps you know him as the creepy murderer in television's messy yet underappreciated scifi body-swapper mystery "Dollhouse." Or maybe you know him most from the very best episodes of the very best TV show, "Strangers with Candy," when he played the leader of the cult that wanted to "sit at the welcome table." As Steve the Pirate in Dodgeball? That dude from "Firefly"? The pedophile on "CSI"? I would call him the man of a thousand faces but he really has just one face and it's magical! Oh, Alan Tudyk! His latest role is that of an insane and likely Austrian and definitely repressed computer hacker and reformed assassin and probable homosexual in Transformers: Dark of the Moon and he achieves the feat of being the one actor who openly mocks this hideous and outrageously expensive-looking film from within. YOU WIN, Alan Tudyk! You are the best.
And the competition is tough: there's a spray-tanned John Malkovich going real big; an absolutely bonkers physical comedy endurance routine from Ken Jeong; Frances McDormand vacillating between phone-in and terrifying commitment as a chief spook; a big and effortlessly campy John Turturro splatter-painting of a performance. That is a lot of actors trying things without much supervision and, to be fair, they're all winners in the losing battle of man versus machine.
You know that it goes without saying that this is a terrible movie. (And unlike MANY of you OTHER pretend film critics (ahem), I have indeed seen them all three Transformers movies. Not only that, I have seen the entirety of the monster bomb that was GI Joe, so I know where the baseline is.)
Knowing that, the point becomes: is this a movie that you can slip into and forget about your life for a few hours? The answer, happily, is "mostly yes."
There are the appearances of plot obstacles to be resolved. It's not all too confusing. The dialogue is jarring and nonsensical and very broad with lots of swearing, so it keeps you engaged and you forget that you're watching Hasbro toys. Shia Labeouf talks a lot. His girlfriend juts her parts as needed.
But on a scale of terribletude, it's really so much better than the other two Transformers movies! There is actually some attention paid to some visual staging and someone decided that there should be a story, and then made sure to express every nook and cranny of the story in real-time, and then helpfully gave us flashbacks to very slightly earlier in the movie! (Remember that part where humans went to the moon and found aliens, which was also the main point of the movie's trailer (and also THE SUBTITLE) which you have been shown 1000 times? Well JUST IN CASE you didn't remember the CENTRAL PREMISE OF THE MOVIE, here are some little flashbacks! That is unreal!)
And somehow still, there was a point at which I started working out a tax issue in my head and then came back when I remembered I was at a movie. So it's not a total success.
What I'll remember most about this final Transformers movie is that there were three different U.S. presidents in the film and somehow they couldn't find an actor who looked like Kennedy, Nixon or Obama. (This is Brett Stimely, the dude who played Kennedy. I mean, why not just pick any random white person off the street?) In a movie that is mostly made of pixels, that just seems impossible, or perhaps actively hostile.






Alan Tudyk — good in this, GREAT in his intermittent gig as 'Anthony Rapp'.
I know when you found yourself in the throes of tax policy: when Patrick Dempsey (not acting!) launched into his endless accounting-based conspiracy theory of why no one goes to the moon anymore.
"His girlfriend juts her parts as needed." Heart.
I loved this line from the Times review, which was also the pull-quote for the blurb at the bottom of the front page: "Transformers: Dark of the Moon is by far the best 3-D sequel ever made about gigantic toys from outer space."
Show some respect, Choire. He was also the dot-com millionaire who purchased the radio station on Frasier
Don't forget Alan Tudyk in the British 'Death at a Funeral.' So great.
As you know, Choire, I saw GI Joe.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/gog/movies/g.i.-joe-the-rise-of-cobra,1151618/critic-review.html
Contains a similar pull quote as AO Scott's for T3: "As polished and entertaining as war-mongering toy commercials get!"
He also dated Tyra from Friday Night Lights. Wikipedia said it so it's true. So he is basically better than everyone.
He was totally fun in A Knight's Tale as well.
I decided long ago that the plastic dinosaurs on Serenity's dashboard were his idea.
Um, I think when you wrote "bizarre Sandra Bullock vehicle" what you really meant to write was "greatest movie ever." Just correcting that for you.
Seems like Stimely is carving out a niche for himself. He also played Kennedy in "Watchmen."
This has challenged me in a deeply personal, wholly unexpected way. I just assumed I would never see this movie, and would never even have the slightest urge to see it. But after learning that it involves a spray-tanned John Malkovich doing whatever one does when one goes "real big," I really want to see it.
@Graydon Gordian There are a lot of very broad, almost slapstick-y comedic performances in this movie. Much more so than I expected, and they mostly work.
@Graydon Gordian Every second Malkovich role involves him going really big. Just see Con Air instead. Bonus: includes John Cusack thinking himself really handsome.
"this final Transformers movie": aren't you the optimist!
I saw GI Joe and Transformers 2 as a back-to-back double feature at a drive in. They were pretty much made to be watched on a tailgate with a bunch of beer.
@hazmathilda But what movie wasn't? As far as I'm concerned, Schindler's List was made to be watched on a tailgate with a bunch of beer.
@SidAndFinancy I feel the same way about Shoah!
"You got a job, we can do it, don't much care what it is."
The non-Kennedy Kennedy also played President Kennedy in "Watchmen" according to imdb. What the hell?
Uh, FACTUAL ERROR: All white people look the same. What are you trying to pull here, The Awl? The People demand answers.
@Matt You white? You Ben Affleck/Kennedy.
I am a leaf on the wind; watch me soar.
@Vulpes My friend actually made a shirt that said that for a screening of Serenity. I'm ragging on him for that as we speak.
@Vulpes For me, Wash is Wash forever.
I didn't hate the first movie. I wanted a movie about the toys I played with as a kid that wasn't horrible, and that was all.
As soon as they made sequels, then you can't forgive the lack of a story, racist robots, etc.
@JoshUng I wanted the same thing, but it was horrible. God awful horrible. It just wouldn't end soon enough. The first one was traumatically bad. I'm sorry, I feel really strongly about this.
@whizzard No need to apologize. Though, if I'm honest, I think the one thing I wanted to be was "not as bad as Pearl Harbor." Maybe that's why I thought it was "successful."
Love Alan Tudyk. After seeing him in Dollhouse I realized that he should replace Heath Ledger as The Joker.
Please tell me they all got involved because Joel Cohen was attached.
I absolutely suspect the "Oh, great, The Navy SEALs are here!" scene was slapped together and added as a reshoot after April.
My favorite review of this movie:
http://outlawvern.com/2011/07/02/transformerss-dark-of-the-moon/