Sunday, August 1st, 2010
4

The Pitch: How to Remake 'Les Miserables' Into the Next 'Twilight'

HUDGIEIn 1995, French director Claude Lelouch adapted Les Miserables for the screen. Instead of post-Revolutionary France, he transposed the story to Nazi-occupied France. Though this adaptation didn't get much attention in the states, it's very successful. You can imagine the parallels during the time periods–and the actors are very good. Perhaps the success of this adaptation pushed for an American film version of the musical. In 1998, Les Miserables was released starring Liam Neeson as Valjean, Geoffrey Rush as Javert, Uma Thurman as Fantine, and Claire Danes as Cosette. It was a flop. ("Made me feel transported back to high school history class," wrote Roger Ebert.) It's easy as a director to get too confident when you have Liam Neeson and Geoffrey Rush on a bill but it was tedious and flat, which is the opposite of the play: frothy, heady-and rich with opportunities for hot European actors to rip their shirts off.

It's as easy as casting it right and not having a horrific script and director.

• Let's get Gerard Butler in there as Javert, with his stocky frame, swarthy facial hair and bulky muscles he's perfect for the role. And hey, he can sort of sing! Remember Phantom of the Opera? No, you probably don't. Well?

MMMMFASSBENDER• Valjean, besieged father and leader of men, is harder to cast, but I for one would love to see the deft German-born Irishman from Inglorious Basterds, Michael Fassbender take on the part. Valjean takes great emotional depth and an openness-we have to feel for him. Fassbender could do this part in his sleep. And he's not hard on the eyes, either. Also, he's European, so he's cheap.

• For Fantine, the mother heroine and mysterious-respiratory-disease haver, let's get some real talent in here, maybe even rack up an Oscar nom. Get me Emily Watson post-haste. Watson has that strong matron-peasant look that simply crackles on screen.

• Cosette is such a boring character that it would take a really talented actress to make her shine. Zoe Kazan is a brute of a girl, in the best way possible. Her small part in Revolutionary Road basically stole the show; she's got the chops and she knows how to use them. Cosette is usually cast as willowy and model-looking – but Kazan could make things interesting.

YOUNG LOVERS• Marius, the featured love interest, is similarly boring. We'd need someone sweet and young-ish, but he'd also need to equal Kazan's power. How about Kazan's real-life boyfriend, Paul Dano? Indie cred: SECURED!

• Eponine, the 14-year-old who sacrifices herself to fulfill the revolutionary role-playing fantasies of her unrequited crush, Marius, is usually played by some vaguely ethnic young lady, mostly likely because Lea Aalonga popularized the part on stage. In movie adaptations she's similarly "exotic." Who better for this part than Eva Green? She sizzles. If we wanted to pack the tweens into the seats-and who doesn't-we may need to take a page from the Disney playbook and cast Vanessa Hudgens.

• For the innkeepers, the skuzzy cajoling wretches that look as though they leaped out of some painting of France's third class, I say no, NO, NO to ruddy and grubby character actors this time. Let's scrub these two up and make it so make the audience wants them to slip their hands in your pocket. Easy: John Slattery and Helen Mirren, overboiled silvery sex pots, those two are.

Okay, Hollywood, I just made your musical as relevant as Twilight with a Lady GaGa soundtrack. Let's get on it.



Jessica Ferri will totally step in and direct it herself if need be.

4 Comments / Post A Comment

Bridget (#6,499)

As a life long Les Mis fan, I don't WANT Les Mis to be like Twilight. Twilight will fade with time: Les Mis is timeless. Heck, the show ended on Broadway and they brought it back within months! I say this as someone who is also a Twilight fan, but Twilight will not last forever, and the films will never be classics (sadly, the quality of the movies ruined the books for me). Anyway, onto the casting. Dano as Marius? Marius may be boring, but he's a dashing swoon-worthy character. While Dano is an EXCELLENT talent, I don't find myself smitten with him in the slightest. And honestly, Vanessa Hudgens? Eponine is my dream role, and Hudgens would smack it in the face. I could barely stand her squeaky voice in HSM. I'd leave the theater if I had to hear her sing the powerhouse "On My Own." Three bits of your casting I like: Butler (who surprised the heck out of me with Phantom), Slattery (aka sexy), and Mirren (genius).

Overall, I'd want Les Mis be a quality movie that may not fill the theaters, rather than a movie like Twilight, that might fill the theater but doesn't have the heart or the quality. Unfortunately, film studios these days focus on what money they bring in, so for them, this cast works. Oh Hollywood, you make me sad.

Bunx05 (#1,625)

No Vanessa Hudgens. I'm sorry, but Disney is just trying to pin us down for a particular type of "acting" and "singing" cultural deep throat. While some of the kids they push have gotten better over the years, in so far as acting is concerned, most have not. And none of their voices are worth while.

Fassbender is genius. I don't know why he isn't working more in the States, though he will be playing Magneto in the new X-Men reload next to James McAvoy's Professor X, so Hollywood may be catching up to us nerds.

Oh, and while I do not swoon over the character of Marius, I know that women are supposed to. So, I may have to disagree with Dano in the role. I agree with the premise of your argument, just not the conclusion.

Lastly, I think Les Mis should definitely be revamped a little for a new generation. Younger faces would make the work more accessible to a younger generation, and if done right might help revive the arts in the eyes of the youths.

temerson (#7,386)

The Thenardiers should be cast against type – Johnny Depp's turn as Jack Sparrow catapults him to the front of that list, alongside "Public Enemies" flame Marion Cotillard.

This has got to be the stupidest thing I've ever read.
Why on Earth would anyone ever want Les Mis to be like Twilight?
Surely you jest.
I agree that is should be revamped and brought back to life, but no. Not into gimmicky corporate crap.

Post a Comment