How do you sell a car to a bisexual? And if you're bisexual, how do you want to be sold to?
Major corporations that market directly to the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community tempt us to believe that such slippery questions have firm answers. Otherwise, why were we all standing there at the New York International Auto Show this week, on an unseasonable 80 degree night in April, drinking Cadillac's beer?
Last year, General Motors hosted a gay event in the West Village to promote the new Camaro. Its senior PR and marketing staff duly came in from Detroit and answered questions like the sincere, heterosexual Midwesterners they are. I was thrilled when one executive earnestly told me that, as far as he knew, Saturn was the GM brand most popular with transsexuals. (If men are from Mars and women are from Venus, I suppose it follows.)
GM's gay event at this year's Auto Show was styled "A Night OUT with Cadillac"-emphasis original. And for hardcore fans of English language styling, the invitation also contained the irresistible sentence: "Later we'll whisk you away by courtesy motorcoach to a VIP afterglow." (That meant free drinks at the gay bar Therapy.)
At the Auto Show I asked Jason Laird-a lanky Aussie recently relocated to Detroit with his wife and daughters, whose title is "Executive Director, Product & Brand" for GM Communications-why his company was pitching the gays.
"We're marketing cars and trucks, and the fact of the matter is, you have a broad cross-section of the community that wants to experience these in different ways," he said.
"Obviously in the LGBT community, you've got people who are very brand conscious; very aware of the product they're buying. The car generally is the most expensive thing you buy after a house, so it makes sense that you would have a direct discussion with any audience that's interested in your product," he said.
The answer seemed factual but unilluminating: if something is equally true of all groups, then it doesn't help us understand the gay situation specifically.
So I turned to one of the gay GM-ers on hand, social media manager and company LGBT spokesman Joe LaMuraglia, who previously founded the homo-motoring Web site Gay Wheels.
"Having covered [GM] prior to making the decision to join them, they were one of the most progressive companies from my perspective, in that they scored well with HRC [Human Rights Campaign], but anyone I ever came in contact with from management all the way down to PR was very welcoming to what we were trying to do," said LaMuraglia.
He also admitted that carmakers like GM really can't know the sexuality of their customers. But he said that GayWheels had partnered with the market research firm Sorgenfrei to try and provide such information through an opt-in survey on their site.
So-Joe!-how do you sell a car to a bisexual?
"It isn't the person's sexuality, it's the person's lifestyle," he said. "And when you're in marketing or market research or product planning, it's all about life-stages and lifestyles. A gay or lesbian couple in their forties with no kids are very different from a straight couple in their forties with four kids. So it's not really that their sexuality has anything to do with the car they're driving, it's more where their life-stage is."
And that, I suppose, is the unexciting truth. Isn't it what we've been fighting for, all these years? With Stonewall and Silence = Death and rioting on Fifth Avenue a week after Matthew Shepard was murdered-weren't we just demanding the right to be treated like any other schmuck with a buck in this country?
Still hoping for a "VIP afterglow" to the matter, I returned to the lanky Aussie for one last facetious question.
"So, does the Cadillac gear shift have a special feature for limp wrists?"
He looked at me sympathetically.
"You could get an automatic," he said.
Ben Widdicombe is a celebrity and pop-culture columnist, based in Manhattan. Our model, pictured above, is Micah Jesse.

The PR flacks are full of it. Companies do gay-specific events because of the "they noticed us!" effect (See: Hillary Clinton). Certain brands also tend to pull certain demographics; Subaru sponsors Lilith Fair for a reason.
The existence of the LGBT Chamber of Commerce is proof of this: http://www.nglcc.org/
Any self-respecting homosexual would absolutely NOT buy the design travesty that is Cadillac. From tits to tail, it's a disaster.
Nary a Subaru joke to be found?
Actually Lady Gaga tickets are the most expensive thing you can buy after a house.
GM may not mind selling cars to trans people but it certainly doesn't want them to work at their factories. When I still lived in Lansing in 2001-2 a person who worked on the line and transitioned was forced to continue to use the men's room, and be ostracized by her coworkers while her supervisors ignored the problem.
A gay or lesbian couple in their forties with no kids are very different from a straight couple in their forties with four kids.
Hey, I'm half of a mid-30s straight couple with no kids. DO WE HAVE TO BUY THE GAY CAR NOW?
Not only do LGBTs not have children they have no child support payments and no alimony payments to make i.e., DINKS = dual income no kids. They can say it's about the lifestyle all they want but they are trawling the last sector of the population with money.
"They are trawling the last sector of the population with money."
Rather than make good vehicles. In 2001, I got rid of my '94 Pontiac Bonneville (SSEi supercharged) with 86k and nothing more than standard maintenance. This was the last decent car to come out of GM, in my opinion.
They "improved" it for the 2000 model year, which started the deathwatch for Pontiac. It became obvious around the same time that GM was interested in, "style" (ahem) over substance; that's what's killed General Motors.
It was solid, fast, well-crafted, good looking, and reliable: generally the opposite of any GM vehicle I've had to drive in the last ten years.
Comparing a '94 Bonneville to a 2000 Bonneville to make some sort of statement about GM in 2010 is incredibly pointless.
How do you figure?
1994 = good vehicles
2000 = mediocrity seeps in
2010 = well, at least it's shiny! The geighs will buy it!
Kitten, thanks for perpetuating the rich-fags myth that's been debunked by actual economists like M.V. Lee Badgett.
I didn't say they were rich. I just meant to point out that they don't have the same financial baggage of the straights. The demographic they usually woo got soaked in either the real estate bubble or the market crash. I am not saying that a gay person or couple wouldn't be in that same situation but it is less likely they would have kids or alimony on top of that.
It's true - The Gays tend to have more disposable income, which is why they're a coveted demographic. Especially in the 35+ age brackets. I have done a lot of work on getting ready to market things like retirement communities and assisted living facilities to the gay Boomer demographic.
Kitten and Pete J. Hawk, you are in fact both incorrect, based on the actual peer-reviewed science published by legitimate economists. Pete in particular is falling prey to naïve belief in marketing surveys, which, like tobacco-industry-sponsored cancer studies, tend to have a predetermined rosy outcome.
The vast preponderance of economic surveys of lesbian and gay incomes show that gay males have lower incomes than straight males, often by noticeable margins, while lesbians have higher incomes than straight women, typically by small margins.
It is an outright myth (where "myth"Â means "falsehood"Â or "lie") that fags generally or even commonly earn more than straight guys. Dressing up that myth with buzzwords like "DINKs" and "[t]he Gays have more disposable income" won't make it true.
Here's just a quick skill-testing question: Of the three of us, who has actually read the economics literature?
I'm more curious about how you market cool-ranch doritos to gay people.
I'm going to spare my parents any further confusion and just never ever buy a car.
I'm wondering why they're marketing cars to LGBT people in a city where nobody drives. I mean, shouldn't New York have a commuter bus and monorail show, instead?
Just like North Haverbrook!
Home of the Monorail Cafe!
This will cetainly be one to watch in countries were opel and vauxhall are only present in europe with Cadillac's expansion plans for the future with the xts 2010 concept.
Duesenberg.