Thursday, April 15th, 2010
30

Chocolate Chip: Tyler Perry Just Keeps On Presenting

OH HERIf you're white and/or Jewish like Hollywood, I'm sure you've been scratching your head recently thinking: "Jeepers! If the smarty blacks don't like Tyler Perry eeeeither, how have his movies managed to gross hundreds of millions of dollars? I daresay IIIIIII haven't seen one of them." Well crackers, The Tyler Perry Effect is REAL. Oprah, get to steppin'! There's another full-size black media mogul with big titties ready to take your place.

That's right people. It is time to talk Tyler Perry. The man who somehow jacked RuPaul's "Most Famous Black Drag Queen in America" tiara, who is pissed at Spike Lee for being so goddamn smart and black. The man who comforted Janet Jackson after her bro took that last Propofol cocktail, the man determined to enter the American zeitgeist even if the uppity blacks and the regular whites don't want him there.

Hollywood's been feeling peckish about the success of this black individual and his attempt to alter the American film and television landscape. His formula, well documented by now, is simple: take one of the most underrepresented populations in the country, make them suffer, offer redemption, stir in a healthy dose of Christian dogma, star and include your full name followed by the word "Presents" in the title of each of your movies and upset the hoity-toity, cantankerous (read: "educated") blacks of the north by using trusted racial stereotypes that may still harbor fraught historical implications, but doggone it! they make us laugh. Oh, and yes, lest I forget-as often as possible, do it in DRAG.

Perry has a lot of haters. Indeed, when he went to California to get studio backing for his first film, he was met with rejection. It went like this:

Tyler Perry's Midnight Train From Georgia

TYLER PERRY: [rather naïvely and with a faint southern accent] My loyal fan base consists of an unprecedented number of black, churchgoing females!!!!

HOLLYWOOD: [lamenting the golden era of Quaaludes] Black people who go to church don't go to movies.

Fin.

I agree with Hollywood. Since when are God-fearing, Christian Negresses fans of movies with cross-dressing, gun packing, weed smoking, crack peddling, wife beating, pussy selling black folks? "He realized that there is a segment of the black community that would define itself as churchgoing, and that simply has no interest in what Hollywood, the stage, and, to a certain extent, the music industry was offering," is what Mark Anthony Neal, a professor of black popular culture at Duke University said for a feature on Perry in the New York Times. Well, I define myself as a woman responsible enough to treat others with respect but I'll be damned if I let some crazy bitch step into my house without knowing the rules. In other words, like "high holiday" Jews that bang the goy (and, LOL, schvartzes too!) there are "high holiday" blacks that define themselves as "churchgoing" even though they only show up at church on Easter and Christmas.

Perry bankrolled his first film with his own money. Now he is entirely made of money, because he owns it all. And since then, Perry's original fan base has evolved, unlike his films. Those primitive, feel-good, sanctified productions filled with the Holy Ghost now appeal to black women who want to watch movies about other black women (or black men in drag). These are women who, when not scrounging around trying to make ends meet while their baby daddy is in jail, get bored and want to watch movies in which a black man prances around in a wig and fake boobies, waving a gun and carrying an assortment of belts in his purse in case he needs to open up a can of whoopass. Genius. Duh!

And then there's Oprah. "Do not play him small because he is not just some lucky rich Negro-turned-black man" she said of Perry in an interview with 60 Minutes. Perry has been compared to Oprah because of his Midas touch; his fan base is so loyal, so driven and committed to his films that they'll likely come out even if he starts adding quality to his work. The recent success of the indie favorite Precious, a film Perry produced with Oprah, suggests Oprah may be grooming Perry as she carefully shapes the final act of her legacy. His success is only growing.

Now, I know people love them some Oprah, but if you're like me (raised by a single black man), you were taught to think of Oprah as a man-hating devil woman with lots of money and a big mouth. In short: every black man's nightmare. So, when Oprah makes a laudatory comment about a black man, you know shit is going to go DOWN. When Perry was broke and thinking about how his father used to beat him like Kunta Kinte, it was Oprah who said, let there be light, influencing Perry to pick up a pen and create his cash cow Madea. Since then, Perry is one of the highest earners in the industry that won't even have him.

Is all the flack Perry's received justified? Can't a man wear drag and make movies in peace? Riddle me this: If Barack and Michele Obama are the paragons of black culture, why are the characters in Perry's resoundingly successful "black" films so different from our first, first black family? If the themes in "Tyler Perry Presents…" are universal, than why would his movies only appeal to churchgoing black women? There are so many questions about this man it makes my weave turn. I think this means that Tyler Perry is just another extremely astute businessman-a perfect foil (as well as body double) for Oprah.

Let's wrap this up with chitlins. Ever had ‘em? They are an acquired taste-you either love to love them, love to hate them or learn to enjoy them in spite of their bad smell. This is much like Tyler Perry's movies. "Yeah. Superstar of the Chitlin' Circuit, I'll take that," Perry said in his 60 Minutes interview. It will be interesting to see, if Perry ever distributes his films overseas, how they are received in other parts of the world. Here in the U.S., the summer flick Death at a Funeral clearly rips some of Perry's formula and the brothas at Mo Money Taxes knew a good thing when they saw it, too. They turned Perry's fat black cash cow into a much funnier, albeit derivative, fat white parody.

I cannot at heart be a hater. I'm always glad to see a black man making money, but I hope Perry is smart enough to use his new-found fame and fortune to diversify his oeuvre because all black women don't go to church. That diversification is way overdue. I want a movie about black women that speaks to me too, thank you very much. I can see it now: "Charlie Presents: Charlie's Charlie." It's a blockbuster waiting to HAPPEN.



Charlie is the pen name of a young woman in New York City who is merely hungry to see something that represents her experience (however confusing and slutty it may be).

30 Comments / Post A Comment

punkthis (#243)

I've been going over this for ages and I still don't know exactly how I feel about TP and this article articulates my feelings/discomforts pretty damn well. Thanks Charlie, +1, etc. This isn't much of a value-add comment, but MORE CHARLIE.

Bittersweet (#765)

Yes, please!

Baroness (#273)

I shall subscribe to her news-letter, oh yes.

Yes! This is the first time I have enjoyed anything even remotely associated with Steven Tyler.

maebefunke (#154)

As a Tyler Perry starter kit I recommend "I Can Do Bad All By Myself." Not only is there an awesome attempted murder-by-dropping-radio-in-bathtub, but Gladys Knight and Mary J. Blige are around to remind you that everything's gonna be ok.

If that's not enough, just chug your iced wine every time Medea acts totally insane.

Fredrick (#268)

I flipped over to Diary of a Mad Black Woman by accident once, and only stuck around for ten minutes, but it was the most insane shit I'd seen all that day, so I recommend that one.

Diary was the first Perry movie I saw. I cannot tell you how shocked I was to find that there was an audience out there who thought any part of that was funny and/or watchable.

tigolbitties (#2,150)

i might recommend "the family that preys". b/c the ticket was free, i ended up sitting in a theater filled with undergrads from a large university in illinois – who cheered, fucking cheered, when the lead actress got pimp slapped by her husband.

Habit (#4,439)

"Jamilah Lemieux"? What is that, the absurd NPR version of LaShondalay?

What's funny is how Precious sits at the apex of what Tyler Perry Presents, and it's treated like the greatest moving picture of the minute, whereas the rest of his ouvre is considered swill and nonsense and "coonery".

conklin (#364)

Tyler Perry, Justin Bieber, Saw movies: all filed in my "Things that are a really big deal to a lot of people that I will probably never experience firsthand" folder.

HiredGoons (#603)

I like you.

Bunx05 (#1,625)

I like you too.

This is as much as I know about Tyler Perry and his movies. And, as mixed as my feelings might be about Mande, I kinda gotta side with him on this one.

swizzard (#329)

What I think is what effect (if any) the down-low plotline in DAAF* has on TP's audience's opinions regarding an African-American Bachelor of a Certain Age who's bffs w/Oprah, loves cross-dressing, and is suspiciously shiny (or am I the only one who thinks that/finds it suspicious?)

I dunno, I've suspected the guy of Playing for the Home Team for many a year now, and am baffled by the apparent lack of dialogue on the subject.

*Caveats: I'm aware that DAAF is adapted from a Foreign (British?) film; I haven't seen the orig so I don't know if the hidden homosexuality plotline is 'imported,' nor the extent to which DAAF explicitly frames it within the larger cultural practice of 'the down-low.' Also, the plotline is clearly presented as absurd, what with the white midget partner; this could be enough to locate any black male homosexuality (discussed) in the movie squarely in the humorously 'other' category in viewer's minds. (I.e. Boning Peter Dinklage:Af-Am Homosexuality::Watermelon patch on the White House front lawn: Af-Am President, kinda)

Swizz, Are you crazy or something? There are no gay black people.

I dunno but Peter Dinklage plays the role in both versions.

City_Dater (#2,500)

Tyler Perry has gayface, no question about it.
But "don't ask, don't tell" is going to remain the rule in churchgoing, gay-hating, family-first populations long after the military drops it.

Bunx05 (#1,625)

That plotline is the same in the British version, which was hilarious and (from what I can tell from the previews) presented with more heart.

But let's be honest…Dinklage is the f***in man! Did you see him in "In Bruges"? His drunk 'race war' rant was hilarious.

And yes … TP is probably closeted … which is unfortunate.

Renate (#360)

I liked the comparing of Tyler Perry movies to chitlins; something else I will have absolutely nothing to do with.

Aatom (#74)

She's so Charlie.

kpants (#719)

"and yes, lest I forget-as often as possible, do it in DRAG." At this point in pop culture, perceived emasculation is merely a time-tested formula to achieve success for black male performers – Flip Wilson/Geraldine, for instance. A supposedly Christian ethos layered over the top is just the gravy poured atop it all to disguise the already stale comedy underneath.

Swass LikeMe (#1,317)

I wasn't aware that Tyler Perry productions were a type of proselytization until I read the linked NYT article. I initially compared him to Linda Bloodworth-Thomason – somebody who found success articulating a Southern voice previously dismissed by Hollywood. The Oprah comparison is apt, but I don't know if she shares the same quasi-evangelical platform as Perry. (Or should I say crazy-evanglical platform?)

I don't hate Perry for producing feel-good boilerplate comedies stocked with cliche characters. (I sure like a good Bloodworth-Thomason sitcom after all.) However I dislike his apparent belief in prosperity theology, and his desire to integrate it into his work.

Good post, Charlie.

Fancy (#4,084)

I'm part of the black buj and I've twice watched his shit by accident and ended up really liking what I saw. He's not a bad writer if you can get over what only appears to look like stock characters and tired plots. I like that Tyler Perry just says 'fuck the Cosbys.' They put us in the brownstone as doctor, lawyer. Hell, we're in the G-d white house. And *SNAP* racism is over now. So, can we have our weed-smoking granny characters back??

skahammer (#587)

Good Christ this post was informative. Stop making me learn, Awl!

Crantastical (#4,127)

Has he ever explained why he feels the need to dress up like an old woman?

Bunx05 (#1,625)

So, being a card carrying member of the 'uppity blacks', I am both repulsed and in some way drawn to TP's work.

On the one hand, I am sick of 'those' black characters being paraded around like that is how black people have to be. Notice the assholes in his movies are very successful black males who have high power jobs and thus are no longer black. They beat their wives, cheat, spend no time with their children and probably suck Satan's big hairy one. Being a married black male with some money in a very good job, this pisses me off. Then again, I fall into the 'other uppity black guy' column: married to whitey.

On the other side, his characters are very close to real people (albeit people none of us want to claim). Madea is almost exactly like my ugly gun-wielding aunt (except that she's not a man). Plus, he's finally gotten more black people in movies and television (albeit the type of asses we've spent years trying to keep off television).

My real issue is the fact that when I teach my half black daughter about 'black culture', this is the swill she'll see on TV and in movies. She'll end up growing up seeing this shit as what 'real black people' are like. I don't want her to identify as black only, but if this is what she'll be identifying with … ugh.

Pandemic Endemic (#3,825)

Is Tyler Perry stealing back minstrel shows from the whites in exchange for the whites having stolen jazz from the blacks?

josh_speed (#97)

Yes, it would seem.

Atencio (#399)

I've read this post like 3 times and I still can't tell if it's racist or what.

Habit (#4,439)

It is. Call Rush Limbaugh and report it. Quick.

Post a Comment