Don't forget, Roiphe has gotten it seriously wrong about DFW before (though she wasn't the worst offender in this instance): http://www.slate.com/id/2221834/
On Booked Up, with Seth Colter Walls: An Incredibly Un-Fun Misreading of David Foster Wallace that Katie Roiphe Should Never Do Again
Don't forget, Roiphe has gotten it seriously wrong about DFW before (though she wasn't the worst offender in this instance): http://www.slate.com/id/2221834/