Stop Renaming Neighborhoods
"The real action, though, was on the side streets, populated by the myriad businesses needed to produce a garment, making everything from fabric to pins and needles. There machines and people worked day and night filling the orders left by buyers from across the country. I remember pushing my way through the hundreds of master cutters and patternmakers who crowded the sidewalk along 38th Street at lunchtime, dodging the hand trucks carrying stylish garments that later appeared on the backs of women from east coast to west. This is what the words 'garment district' meant. Every one recognized the garment district not just as a geographic designation, but also as a living entity."
—Jewelry historian Jean Appleton argues against a business association proposal to change the name of Manhattan's Garment District to the "Fashion District." Doing so, she said, would "erase a vital part of New York's past." I still can't over how anyone thought it could be a good idea to change the name of neighboring Hell's Kitchen to "Clinton." Hell's Kitchen is the greatest neighborhood name in the history of the planet.







Swampoodle.
@sorry your heinous: One of the very best names around. East of the River there are even better names for the old subdivisions. Looking at old maps I found one that was something like, "Wizard's Hold." or something like that. Just Brilliant.
@theheckle That is fantastic!
I'm also in favor of keeping the Garment District AND Hell's Kitchen. Clinton would be better if it were named "Bill Clinton." (For some reason that seemed funnier to me when I thought about it than seeing it here, oh well.)
You know how on 7th Ave in the Garment District there are street signs that say "Fashion Avenue"? Once I heard a guy on a phone say, "I'm on Fashion Avenue." So yeah, let's stick to Garment District.
Ugh the worst was when I heard someone refer to the area in Brooklyn around Franklin as "Pro-Cro."
I live in a neighborhood (Prospect Lefferts Gardens) that everyone assumes was recently coined by realtors but in fact is more than 40 years old. Before that, apparently, it was known as "Pigtown." Which I think is a better name than even Hell's Kitchen.
In its Community Health Profiles, the Health Department refers to the neighborhood as Chelsea-Clinton, which still cracks me up.