Thursday, April 28th, 2011
49

'L.A. Noire': Interactive's Big Night

The other night I attended the premiere of a video game. It was an odd little duck—the premiere, that is. The video game is L.A. Noire, an interactive thriller from Rockstar Games (coming out in May), and it was not odd at all. But the premiere was a bit of a puzzle.

In many aspects, it was more traditional roll-out than premiere—a demonstration of the product, followed by prepared remarks from the company and then a Q&A for the fans. But this was not Comic Con or E3 Expo, where we’d expect a whole weekend’s worth of such events; this was at the Tribeca Film Festival. And to answer the question of why L.A. Noire was occupying a slot at the Festival was Geoff Gilmore, the host for the event and also the festival's chief creative officer (and former longtime director of the Sundance Film Festival). Gilmore has no small amount of cinema street cred in the bank, and he was visibly excited to present this premiere of what he described as “a whole new sphere of storytelling: narrative gaming.”

The movie business and the video game business (or the “interactive” business, as it's known) have been flirting for some time. Blockbusters get licensed to interactive producers for video games (even E.T.!), and sometimes games get developed into movies (i.e., the Resident Evil series). Each of course is vying for a sometimes-overlapping audience, but as technologies advance and delivery platforms begin to resemble each other, this flirtation is becoming a bit more serious, though still awkward. And the tone of the event, from the perspective of Gilmore and the TFF, was an invite to the interactive industry to go back to cinema’s room later that night. Interactive, from the tone of Rockstar, is playing hard to get. The company's reps, Rob Nelson and Simon Ramsey, while seeming pleased to be there, were clearly more focused on promoting the game than celebrating any potential union between the sectors. When asked to identify the game's ideal audience, Ramsey answered that Rockstar was not just looking to Rockstar fans (who comprised the majority of the audience), but also to fans of film noir. And what better venue to reach these fans than a high-profile film festival? And if the initial outreach to cineastes is in the guise of a serious discussion of the arts, then so much the better.

The game itself is a bright shiny thing. Immaculately art-directed, it takes place in the Los Angeles of 1947, and the protagonist (“you”) is a WWII hero recently promoted to detective, trying to solve a series of grisly (and graphic) murders. The animation of the characters' faces was mapped using a new process that approximates photographic-level graphics, and it's impressive, as is the richness of the period LA scenery. It was written and directed by Brendan McNamara, and features a cast of 400 and a “script” of 2,300 pages. As progress in the game is ultimately determined by engaging in a series of interrogations of potential suspects in which you, the player, must determine the truthfulness of statement—literally by choosing between Truth/Doubt/Lie after each interogatee response—both the script and the facial animation are much more important than they would be in, say, a first-person shooter.


As pretty as the game is, the product demo of the game was an interesting experience, in the full sense of that word. It was novel, if not newsworthy, to get a peek at the next big Rockstar game (considering their track record), and at the same time it was squirmy. The demo was a live projection of one of the Rockstar team playing an early chapter, and watching a stranger play a videogame is as stultifying as it sounds. The cut scenes which lay out the arc of the story are fun, but when the game proceeds into actual play there are small gaps and pauses that the gamer takes in stride when playing but are less than riveting for those looking over his shoulder. All of the dull parts of game play—driving the car from scene to scene, climbing the stairs—were live and in real time. And to watch and not be distracted by mashing your thumbs, your attention is freed to wander and notice the little things, good and bad—the richness of the sound design, and the incongruity between near-human facial gestures and weirdly mapped fabric (which is notoriously hard to depict via CGI). A live demonstration was not as evocative as perhaps the organizers had hoped.

That point where video games are so immersive as to become watchable by third parties is not that far away, though, and L.A. Noire is a clear effort to approach that point. It’s very pretty and very well realized, but at the same time, the fact that the mechanics are based on interrogations, on an immense but still finite logic tree, can be reminiscent of reading a souped-up “Choose Your Own Adventure” book. Above all this, the decision of the TFF to “premiere” L.A. Noire, is a component of the engaging gospel of Geoff Gilmore: finding the places where cinema overlaps similar media, and to even find a Unified Field Theory of Narrative. And while L.A. Noire may not be the apotheosis of that, the event was a window on the ways the two industries will step on each other’s toes while they consider the prospect of finally getting it on.



Brent Cox is all over the Internet.

49 Comments / Post A Comment

deepomega (#1,720)

Worth noting that the way they got the facial animation in LA Noire by literally recording actors' faces (in full makeup and hair) performing their lines. So it's not just "a well-animated game", it's a game that is far closer to actual performance.

wallsdonotfall (#6,378)

Interesting that the concept of narrative gaming goes at least back to the Zork text-based games, and that a very similar technique of filming actors was used for the graphical Return to Zork back in 1993. It even had similar conversation mechanics–when interviewing characters, the player could steer the conversation by responding with a happy, curious, or threatening face, which might get the characters to change their story.

deepomega (#1,720)

@wallsdonotfall Oh man don't get me started on adventure games! The peak of the videos-of-actors thing was probably the Tex Murphy series which, coincidentally, was also about a detective. The whole "thinking about multiple things to say to people" probably lends itself well to detective games.

grandpa27 (#804)

What I really like to see are those caned chairs shown at the beginning.

saythatscool (#101)

So video games are now art? The corners of Roger Ebert's neckhole just imperceptibly shifted downwards.

Danzig! (#5,318)

@saythatscool That, or the biggest entertainment business in existence!

So that's what the cast of Wings is up to.

Danzig! (#5,318)

Insert comment here on the problems that result from games aping film.

Also, play Alpha Protocol you shits!

shostakobitch (#1,692)

Why not just watch a computer animated movie? I always feel like pressing "any key" and skipping the cut scenes whether it is M. Bison gloating at my defeat or the death of Woody from diabetes or whatever killed him (can't say I actually saw that one).

clar47luve (#12,416)

I almost always surf any web-site and prefer to be element for your group, as you realize i also has a terribly tigh social aspect and just want to share my understanding for your web-site.
So i hope 1 day I can help any person who really want my enable thanks!!!

urdh22farh (#12,539)

I frequently surf any webpage and wish to be aspect for your neighborhood, as you know i also features a highly tigh social aspect and just want to share my expertise for your webpage.
So i hope one particular day I may help everybody who will need my assist thanks!!!

shat15dana (#12,627)

I mostly surf any web site and like to be element for your local community, as you understand i also features a highly tigh social facet and desire to share my expertise for your web site.
So i hope one particular day I may help everyone who desire my support thanks!!!

fawn58orli (#12,700)

I in most cases surf any web pages and like to be component for your group, as you recognize i also has a highly tigh social facet and need to share my know-how for your web pages.
So i hope one particular day I can help anyone who need my assist thanks!!!

gata55elro (#12,775)

I often surf any web-site and wish to be part for your neighborhood, as you understand i also includes a pretty tigh social aspect and wish to share my knowledge for your web-site.
So i hope 1 day I may also help any person who desire my support thanks!!!

erva55neva (#12,949)

I in most cases surf any web-site and like to be part for your community, as you understand i also includes a quite tigh social facet and just want to share my practical knowledge for your web-site.
So i hope a single day I will help everybody who desire my assistance thanks!!!

rika69garw (#13,016)

I generally surf any internet site and prefer to be element to your community, as you understand i also features a pretty tigh social facet and need to share my practical knowledge to your internet site.
So i hope a single day I might help just about anyone who absolutely need my allow thanks!!!

anno35jeco (#13,057)

I ordinarily surf any internet site and like to be portion for your group, as you know i also features a especially tigh social side and need to share my expertise for your internet site.
So i hope one particular day I may also help everyone who desire my assistance thanks!!!

kale74tsar (#13,621)

I quite often surf any site and wish to be aspect for your neighborhood, as you realize i also features a very tigh social facet and desire to share my knowledge for your site.
So i hope one day I may also help everybody who absolutely need my support thanks!!!

bawi42kend (#13,680)

I regularly surf any websites and like to be portion for your community, as you understand i also features a exceedingly tigh social aspect and desire to share my practical knowledge for your websites.
So i hope one particular day I may help virtually anyone who might need my assistance thanks!!!

dzak53muli (#13,726)

I frequently surf any website and prefer to be aspect to your neighborhood, as you understand i also includes a highly tigh social facet and prefer to share my awareness to your website.
So i hope one day I may help everyone who absolutely need my allow thanks!!!

maha83zisk (#13,907)

I regularly surf any web-site and prefer to be aspect to your group, as you understand i also includes a particularly tigh social facet and desire to share my information to your web-site.
So i hope a single day I may help virtually anyone who desire my benefit thanks!!!

ranj98carl (#14,023)

I ordinarily surf any site and prefer to be aspect to your group, as you recognize i also includes a especially tigh social side and just want to share my expertise to your site.
So i hope 1 day I can help everyone who require my assist thanks!!!

liu82zahir (#14,065)

I typically surf any web pages and wish to be part to your local community, as you already know i also features a especially tigh social facet and desire to share my know-how to your web pages.
So i hope one particular day I will help everybody who will need my benefit thanks!!!

para17hisy (#14,081)

I in most cases surf any web site and like to be element for your community, as you recognize i also features a fairly tigh social side and desire to share my practical knowledge for your web site.
So i hope 1 day I may also help any individual who will be needing my assistance thanks!!!

hepz66sakt (#14,193)

I frequently surf any web-site and prefer to be component for your community, as you understand i also features a quite tigh social facet and need to share my know-how for your web-site.
So i hope a single day I may help virtually anyone who really want my assist thanks!!!

zhil29hami (#16,790)

I normally surf any web site and wish to be element to your local community, as you already know i also has a extraordinarily tigh social aspect and prefer to share my know-how to your web site.
So i hope one day I might help everyone who will be needing my assist thanks!!!

munt88aman (#16,967)

I almost always surf any webpage and wish to be portion to your local community, as you understand i also includes a rather tigh social aspect and prefer to share my awareness to your webpage.
So i hope 1 day I can assist any one who want my support thanks!!!

dona52mufr (#18,033)

I frequently surf any web-site and wish to be component to your neighborhood, as you already know i also has a quite tigh social aspect and prefer to share my know-how to your web-site.
So i hope 1 day I can help virtually anyone who have my enable thanks!!!

litu81zahi (#18,204)

I frequently surf any web site and like to be aspect to your neighborhood, as you know i also includes a truly tigh social side and like to share my awareness to your web site.
So i hope one day I may help anybody who have to have my enable thanks!!!

hels73hara (#19,917)

I almost always surf any web page and wish to be component to your local community, as you realize i also features a exceptionally tigh social facet and wish to share my know-how to your web page.
So i hope one day I can help any individual who will be needing my support thanks!!!

alib33huwa (#21,169)

I generally surf any internet site and prefer to be element to your community, as you understand i also features a really tigh social facet and just want to share my know-how to your internet site.
So i hope 1 day I can help everybody who might need my assistance thanks!!!

arde36jili (#21,366)

I usually surf any web site and prefer to be part to your community, as you realize i also includes a terribly tigh social aspect and like to share my know-how to your web site.
So i hope one day I may help virtually anyone who will want my allow thanks!!!

carl44lang (#23,616)

I often surf any websites and wish to be portion to your group, as you realize i also has a extremely tigh social facet and like to share my understanding to your websites.
So i hope a single day I will help any one who will want my guide thanks!!!

chan46lian (#25,939)

I quite often surf any internet site and like to be component to your community, as you recognize i also has a pretty tigh social side and prefer to share my expertise to your internet site.
So i hope one particular day I can assist any one who absolutely need my assist thanks!!!

evan56nism (#46,951)

I often surf any web pages and like to be part to your neighborhood, as you recognize i also has a tremendously tigh social aspect and desire to share my know-how to your web pages.
So i hope a single day I may help any one who require my benefit thanks!!!

zhab21faki (#58,395)

I in most cases surf any web pages and like to be part for your neighborhood, as you already know i also includes a incredibly tigh social side and just want to share my information for your web pages.
So i hope 1 day I may help anybody who want my allow thanks!!!

ador31herm (#60,447)

I quite often surf any site and like to be portion to your group, as you recognize i also includes a fairly tigh social side and wish to share my information to your site.
So i hope one day I may help any individual who might need my support thanks!!!

algi33huri (#60,660)

I typically surf any internet site and like to be portion to your neighborhood, as you understand i also includes a extraordinarily tigh social side and wish to share my understanding to your internet site.
So i hope one particular day I may help everyone who need my assist thanks!!!

jia717tahi (#74,014)

I generally surf any web page and like to be component for your neighborhood, as you realize i also includes a tremendously tigh social aspect and want to share my expertise for your web page.
So i hope one particular day I may also help any person who will want my help thanks!!!

hon677sask (#99,461)

I commonly surf any site and wish to be part to your local community, as you understand i also has a exceedingly tigh social aspect and choose to share my know-how to your site.
So i hope 1 day I may help any individual who require my aid thanks!!!

meh858aiko (#112,596)

I in most cases surf any internet site and prefer to be portion to your group, as you realize i also features a extraordinarily tigh social side and choose to share my understanding to your internet site.
So i hope one day I may help everybody who will need my benefit thanks!!!

bel424kenw (#151,140)

I in most cases surf any web site and like to be element for your neighborhood, as you recognize i also features a exceedingly tigh social facet and need to share my expertise for your web site.
So i hope a single day I can help anybody who need to have my allow thanks!!!

ari376jone (#161,749)

I commonly surf any site and prefer to be portion for your community, as you understand i also includes a exceedingly tigh social aspect and wish to share my information for your site.
So i hope a single day I can assist any individual who require my help thanks!!!

lea808yelu (#166,870)

I in most cases surf any web site and like to be component for your neighborhood, as you already know i also has a exceedingly tigh social side and desire to share my expertise for your web site.
So i hope one particular day I may also help virtually anyone who would need my assistance thanks!!!

alb233diwe (#175,726)

I normally surf any web page and like to be portion to your community, as you know i also has a particularly tigh social facet and like to share my information to your web page.
So i hope one particular day I can help anyone who would need my support thanks!!!

aki706cord (#177,907)

I commonly surf any internet site and prefer to be element for your group, as you know i also includes a quite tigh social facet and prefer to share my know-how for your internet site.
So i hope a single day I may also help anyone who demand my guide thanks!!!

cle119must (#187,556)

I usually surf any internet site and prefer to be part for your community, as you realize i also includes a exceedingly tigh social facet and prefer to share my practical knowledge for your internet site.
So i hope one day I will help virtually anyone who absolutely need my allow thanks!!!

sam202algi (#189,947)

I regularly surf any internet site and wish to be component to your neighborhood, as you realize i also includes a truly tigh social side and need to share my expertise to your internet site.
So i hope one day I may help virtually anyone who will need my assistance thanks!!!

jum732thah (#193,779)

I frequently surf any websites and like to be part for your group, as you recognize i also has a extraordinarily tigh social aspect and choose to share my information for your websites.
So i hope one particular day I can assist everyone who need to have my aid thanks!!!

Post a Comment