Quantcast
 

Friday, February 5, 2010

29

Elements of Stale: Having Had Been Buffaloed

BUFFALO'DA friend emailed me last week. The subject line read: "Have you seen this?" The body of the email was without text-just a pasted in Wikipedia entry for "Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo."

This is what the body of the email looked like: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_buffalo_Buffalo_buffalo_buffalo_buffalo_Buffalo_buffalo.

What the fuck, I thought, before actually clicking on. Who was mocking my city like this? Buffalo, NY has a proper Wikipedia entry; I'd read it countless times before. This "Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo" entry then must be a joke.

But a joke about what? Was the Wiki entry mocking how people who are from Buffalo always tend to find a way to bring up their city in conversation? Or was it a virus meant to trap people who are from Buffalo, NY? Surely the only people to click on such a ridiculous link are those with a severe complex about where they are from. Those who remember with pride, for instance, that Governor Mario Cuomo announced he'd be rooting for the Buffalo Bills in the 1991 Super Bowl, a historic game, where we'd play the New York Giants. Mario's reasoning was that the Giants played their home games in New Jersey, and as such the Bills were New York State's home team. Well?

Finally I opened the link. (Not to real talk, but even if it wasn't safe for work, I don't have a job anyhow, so no harm in boldness.) And it turns out the eight Buffaloes actually comprise one grammatically correct sentence. It took me a really long time to understand how this was so. Apparently my attention span is so warped that a string of eight words, even if they're all the same word, is difficult to read.

To read the sentence properly, it helps to know that "buffalo" can function as a verb. When it does, it means "to bully" or "to intimidate." For example, the bar exam I will be taking later this month still buffaloes me.

Also know that in this particular sentence when "buffalo" is capitalized it functions as an adjective, and not as the city Mario Cuomo considers part of New York State. As an adjective it means "from Buffalo." Think Buffalo Bills, or even Buffalo wings. (That is, by the way, why they're called that.)

If you wedge an imaginary "that" (or a "who," if you really want to anthropomorphize the buffalo) between the second and third words of the sentence, it reads better. Which is to say, Buffalo buffalo [who] Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo. However, the sentence remains slightly odd: the city of Buffalo doesn't have buffalo of its own. In fact, the ones at the Buffalo zoo are actually American Bison. (Note though that in the preceding sentence, "Buffalo" is functioning as an adjective.)

It would be really useful to diagram this sentence. Luckily, we learned how to do that in 10th grade. Unfortunately, like many things about high school, I don't remember how I did it. Just that I did. For instance, that year we also read Macbeth, but all I seem to remember was that the emo kids were all "out, out brief candle." This too, even after we had to read it and then listen to it read to us, and then read it again. There was possibly something about a porter who took a whiskey drink and then a vodka drink. And a Banquo. But how to visually conceptualize a sentence? That memory faded quicker than Mario's presidential prospects.

OK so if you are in fact able to wrap your head around the sentence, you'll see it's quite the circle jerk. Buffalo who get bullied by other buffalo bully more buffalo. It's kind of similar to how one kid bullies another kid and then that kid who just got bullied goes and bullies me. Lord of the Flies meets Western New York, if they were buffalo native to this corner of the world. A pecking order of bullshit, that exists primarily within a made-up universe.

That's sort of what grammar is. Right?



Luke Mazur is getting back on the bar exam bandwagon, by George!

29 Comments / Post A Comment

nuch
nuch (#893)

You are from Buffalo and haven't previously had that sentence thrown at you by every English major and word-nerd you come across?

Maybe it was just a North Tonawanda thing.

ContainsHotLiquid

Well I'm from Utica and I've never heard that sentence!

nuch
nuch (#893)

I think if you are >3 hours away it no longer counts as "Buffalo".

Hobbesian
Hobbesian (#255)

Steamed hams!

dr.funke
dr.funke (#336)

Hateful DMV employees are also a North Tonawanda thing. A passive aggressive man-child failed me TWICE when I took my road test in N.Tonawanda.

bong hitler
bong hitler (#3,233)

Will you two stop saying "Gummi" so much?

sergeant tibbs
sergeant tibbs (#1,786)

Coming from Rochester, this is my favorite awkward tidbit to whip out at boring parties.

sorry your heinous

is that a goat?!

barnhouse
barnhouse (#1,326)

Am lighting interior candle on behalf of successful bar exam. I hope you will write and tell us exactly what occurs during a bar exam; I have always wondered that. (Is it questions? Is it essays? How long is it? Are there a bunch of you? Is there an oral part? Do you have to look nice for it? (make sure you shave! etc.)

DorothyMantooth

Seriously? Two days. Both multiple choice & essays.
The NYC one fills the Javits Center.

Now you are an expert!

Setec Astrology

In Virginia, you have to wear a suit. No such decorum required in NY.

barnhouse
barnhouse (#1,326)

Yay! Also, WOW.

sorry your heinous
"And it turns out the eight Buffaloes actually comprise one grammatically sentence. It took be a really long time to understand how this was so."

These two sentences confused me more than the buffalo. Mission accomplished?

johnpseudonym
johnpseudonym (#1,452)

Malo malo malo malo!

petejayhawk
petejayhawk (#1,249)

Dogs dogs dog dog dogs.
Police police police.

HiredGoons
HiredGoons (#603)

You're supposed to call it 'The Scottish Play' you fool!

*(ducks for cover)

josh_speed
josh_speed (#97)

Good luck on the bar exam, foreals!

Kevin
Kevin (#2,559)

I prefer Fuck, it's a lot more versatile.

jfruh
jfruh (#713)

In 10th grade I went to see a production of MacBeth put on by Buffalo's Theater of Youth. It was done with a sort of post-apocalyptic Mad Max aesthetic, and was put on in the enormous disused bomb shelter underneath the main branch of the Erie County public library, and it was as cool as shit. The actors ran through the audience a lot, and the final battle between MacBeth and MacDuff -- in which the latter used a bicycle chain as his weapon, and after knocking down MacBeth slit his throat with a giant knife -- took place around a foot away from him, and I got stage blood on my pants. I've never seen a stage production of anything that would so enthrall a 15-year-old boy and yet also be Legitimate Culture.

johnpseudonym
johnpseudonym (#1,452)

The Broadway production of Showgirls?

ContainsHotLiquid

I love legitimate the-ater.

Patrick M
Patrick M (#404)

I'll diagram it for you, but I need to go get my old Spirograph out of my parents' attic.

SpyMagician
SpyMagician (#2,024)

Here is the source of the whole thing.

And in summary this all means: White people.

brknyc
brknyc (#3,376)

For more sentences that will break your brain slightly:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_while_John_had_had_had_had_had_had_had_had_had_had_had_a_better_effect_on_the_teacher
and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/That_that_is_is_that_that_is_not_is_not_is_that_it_it_is

katiebakes
katiebakes (#32)

Thank you for changing my life.

Jenna Selsky
Jenna Selsky (#3,381)

luke, you make buffalo sound really awesome. i can't wait to take the bar w/ you and wear matching tee shirts and then watch you blog about it wearing mesh shorts over coffee in your new mug/kathie lee and hoda, etc. i hope you pass this time, and also hope you fail.

twoeightnine
twoeightnine (#3,116)

I can't wait for next week when Luke discovers that yes, "You know you're from Buffalo when..."

fairest
fairest (#413)

Do you know that song "Buffalo Nickel" by (I think) Great Lakes Myth Society? Next time, just listen to that song.

Post a Comment

You must be logged-in to post a comment.

Login To Your Account