Quantcast
 

Thursday, October 22, 2009

49

Fight Breast Cancer, Drink Wine... Get Breast Cancer

fat-bastardBecause I have not yet offended every female Awl reader, I would like to point out that it is breast cancer awareness month. [Ed Note: *Hides under desk.*] A consumer holiday created by businesses that discovered placing a pink ribbon on any piece of shit product is a huge sales driver. Yes: "Brands will continue to benefit from identifying and contributing to a positive social purpose that makes sense for their business, with 64 percent of people globally saying they would recommend a brand that supports a good cause (up from 52 percent in 2008)," says the Edelman 2009 Goodpurpose Survey.

Breast cancer awareness month, unlike many other "awareness" campaigns, has done an admirable job of getting awareness to equal action. Many, many worthy causes do necessary work and fundraising to combat the horror of an all-too-common cancer (American Cancer Society 2009 estimates: 192,370 new cases and 40,170 deaths) that strikes women, often in the prime of their lives. They deserve our appreciation. I encourage everyone to list their favorites in the comments.

But then there are many others profiting, both financially and PR-wise. They deserve not only the scorn of breast cancer survivors like Kim Zielinski-("I think that the pink ribbon, as a symbol, tends to pretty up what is a pretty crappy disease. But a pink ribbon is easier to look at than the disease itself.") and LaShaune Johnson ("I cringe when I see that stuff. I feel like they're taking advantage of people who are suffering and want a sense of belonging.")-but ours as well.

First is the NFL. This month the league has convinced stars like Brett Favre to wear gay pink shoes and armbands that are later signed and auctioned to fans. The monies will go to aid research. Also, referees will donate a portion of their earnings. Note that the league itself is not giving much but is reaping the PR. (I first saw this noted on an Awl commenter's wonderful blog but I cannot remember whose so PLEASE IDENTIFY YOURSELF and link!)

Then there is the most egregiously hypocritical, the wine industry: Supporting Breast Cancer Awareness with Wine! Everyone from Fat Bastard to the August Hill Winery (?) are doing special pink-ribboned breast cancer awareness bottles/promotions. All this despite the fact that recent research shows a moderate, but undeniable, link between alcohol and increased breast cancer risk.

49 Comments / Post A Comment

mathnet
mathnet (#27)

"Save 2nd Base"??

Nrbelex
Nrbelex (#1,742)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baseball_metaphors_for_sex#List_of_sexual_metaphors

See "Second base"

Tuna Surprise
Tuna Surprise (#573)

See "Balk" too.

mathnet
mathnet (#27)

Gi! ggle!

mathnet
mathnet (#27)

(That was to you, T. Surprise.)

Bucko
Bucko (#1,599)

ever female reader?

Choire Sicha

All typos are the responsibility of the authors!

Abe Sauer
Abe Sauer (#148)

Bus
|
|
|
V
Abe

resipsaloquacious

What do you have against the privacywear people, Abe?

Peteykins
Peteykins (#1,916)

Awesome contextual advertising, by the way, for a $6,000 pink Rado watch in the upper right corner.

Ronit
Ronit (#1,557)

Also love "GET A TEE GET INVOLVED" on the left, because everyone knows T shirts = activism.

HiredGoons
HiredGoons (#603)

I was not aware of this.

IBentMyWookie
IBentMyWookie (#133)

The link between wine and breast cancer is negligible. Nothing conclusive has been produced.

The larger point made in the Globe article, however, is excellent.

DorothyMantooth

This was the study that came right after the study that found that "moderate" wine drinking helped stave off breast cancer, isn't it?

NicFit
NicFit (#616)

Anytime I see phrases like "modest, but increased risk of..." I cringe. Epidemiological studies are bullshit. The methodologies are inherently flawed and unscientific. They are responsible for the constant stream of conflicting "according to a new study" stories that overwhelm us and make us distrust science.

By the way, when is it appropriate to use "monies" rather than just "money". I have never understood "monies".

kitten_witawip

I think it's when there are multiple sources, like when you are pooling funds.

NicFit
NicFit (#616)

I guess. But "money" is sort of inherently plural, so it's always kind of sounded like "fishes" to me.

NominaStultorum
NominaStultorum (#1,638)

"Fishes" is actually appropriate when you have multiple species of fish. Ask your local ichthyologist.

Moon LaRock
Moon LaRock (#1,394)

I was at an annoying legal writing seminar last week, there was a quiz: Pluralize "money" Monies, right? Pssh, if you want to use a frowned upon variant. Mr. Bryan Garner does not: Moneys

http://books.google.com/books?id=z_VmtjAU01YC&pg=PA223&lpg=PA223&dq=garner+usage+moneys&source=bl&ots=6FeO6g4-I_&sig=TYc9DZZJixjwt737rPSPSuEut9I&hl=en&ei=ttLgSpT_BY3CMLuf-N4M&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CAwQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=&f=false

Abe Sauer
Abe Sauer (#148)

This is a good point. Though, can we agree that there has been shown a connection between heavier drinking and breast cancer?

IBentMyWookie
IBentMyWookie (#133)

No. Again, "a connection" is far too amorphous a term.

Matt
Matt (#26)

My favorite part of the NFL thing is that everything (down to the goddamn brims on the refs' hats) has been branded mauve instead of actual pink, because they apparently felt that to be less 'gay' and more 'manly'.

It's like when they replaced Superman with drunk red-kryptonite Superman in that horrible Kevin Spacey/Kal Penn vehicle.

Bittersweet
Bittersweet (#765)

Mauve? They sure look neon pink to me. Could be my TV, though.

What's worse, the pink accents or those baby-puke Denver throwback uniforms?

garge
garge (#736)

A mea culpa?

I do recall reading in a review for Cuisinart measuring cups that you must register the product for the charitable contribution to be applied. This may not always be the case, but something to be aware of ..

Maevemealone
Maevemealone (#968)

I used to buy this decent red wine, Big Tattoo? Big Red Tattoo? Something like that... at my favorite little Brooklyn wine shop. It's made by two brothers who lost their mother to cancer and decided to make wine and donate a portion to cancer research. Great! I didn't buy it for that reason, I bought it bc if you showed the cashier a tattoo, you got a dollar off the wine. So I guess that's a double edged sword, my tattoo discounted one more dollar towards research? Sorry.

hanna
hanna (#644)

My Ovaltine Indignant Woman secret decoder ring says that "Fat" Bastard, pink ribbon, women, and issues with women parts totally translates to fat chicks and grab-bags of developmental horrors!!

kitten_witawip

Don't you mean "fun bags" of developmental horrors?

bb
bb (#295)

I agree with the gist of this (esp. the NFL example-- booo), but the more alarming thing to me is these horrid new slogans: "save 2nd base" "save the ta-tas" etc. I wish I could make a cogent argument -- perhaps that these encourage cutesifying boobs when they really should be talked about realistically and directly -- but I think it's really just more a matter of snobbery.

cinetrix
cinetrix (#47)

STRONGLY AGREE.

Maevemealone
Maevemealone (#968)

"Crazy Sexy Cancer"

hazmathilda
hazmathilda (#839)

Well the thing is those phrases are framing breast preservation as a thing to be done primarily for the benefit of the men (or whomever is breast-inclined) who will be deriving pleasure from the breasts, not for the bearer of the breasts herself.

/Jezebel, I swear!

kitten_witawip

It's a time honored tradition for women to use their breast to get money from men. I don't think men know that there is any other use for them.

Baboleen
Baboleen (#1,430)

I have a problem when breasts are objectivized by men and the women with not enough self esteem to realize that there is a human being attached to them, but not so much of a problem if the cancerous breast is objectivized and treated. I've never had breast cancer, so I can only assume that first detaching from them, then treating them would feel more powerful.

Those ribbons? I stopped looking at them after 9-11. I almost got into an accident trying to read what they were supporting.

Abe Sauer
Abe Sauer (#148)

e.g., Burton "Save the Melons"
http://pejorativejinx.blogspot.com/2009/10/melon-baller.html

bb
bb (#295)

good one JEZmathilda! no really, good rationale.

Fifi
Fifi (#1,639)

I was waiting to see Blue Oyster Cult at the State Fair this year (yes, I know that I have a sad, sad life), and I was forced to endure an hour of grown men taunting livestock. Long story short, they all wore pink shirts, too.

lostdownunder
lostdownunder (#1,728)

This Barbara Ehrenreich interview about her new book on the problems with optimism has some great stuff about the pink ribbon insanity: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=113758696

Abe Sauer
Abe Sauer (#148)

I love this book.

brent_cox
brent_cox (#40)

It is a fiendish marketing ploy -- "How can you accuse me of undue commodification when I'm fighting *cancer*?" Speaking of which, is the Baffler relaunched yet?

hman
hman (#53)

My mom's a breast cancer survivor and likes the pink ribbon magnet (from Avon, I think!) on her car because she can spot it from further away in the parking lot.
And now my sister - never having had breast cancer - has one too.

slinkimalinki
slinkimalinki (#182)

one of my local bars has a sign up saying "support breast cancer". i snort evilly as i pass it.

mle
mle (#1,292)

RARR! Like at the register at the grocers, "do you want to support breast cancer? do you want to support prostate cancer? do you want to support childhood muscular dystrophy?" what? umm, i don't think so? do I?

sox
sox (#652)

Abe, will you be donning a giant pink ribbon for Halloween? You could be creative with the donation [in a]box...

Abe Sauer
Abe Sauer (#148)

So, you're go as that one day and as this the rest of my life?
http://www.grandforkscounty.net/sheriff/Sex_Offenders.htm

kitten_witawip

So look how cute you are without your hat, pinches Abe's cheek...

http://www.grandforkscounty.net/sheriff/oscar_thompson.htm

Abe Sauer
Abe Sauer (#148)

Ha. Ha. Rapist.

Hez
Hez (#147)

Hooray! Confirmation that Awl writers read our blogs and find them "wonderful"! (Okay, maybe not mine*, but still! Victory!)

[*It is HILARIOUS and SEXY, Abe. Either way, you'll end up pulling something.]

Abe Sauer
Abe Sauer (#148)

Oh, I *have* perused the nerdmare.

Post a Comment

You must be logged-in to post a comment.

Login To Your Account