Quantcast
 

Friday, September 4, 2009

10

Michael Kinsley Finally Catches Up To Renata Adler

DON'T QUIT YOUR DAY JOBMichael Kinsley, Time-firee and bombed LA Times editorial page editor and current Washington Post opinionator, turns his eye to the ridiculousness that is the New York Times correction page. "Who can take facts seriously after reading the daily 'Corrections' column in the New York Times? Although the purpose of this column is to demonstrate the Times's rectitude about taking facts seriously, the facts it corrects are generally so bizarre or trivial and its tone so schoolmarmish that the effect is to make the whole pursuit of factual accuracy seem ridiculous." And where have we read all this before, except much better?

Oh right. The introduction to Renata Adler's 'Canaries in the Coalmine Mineshaft,' which destroyed the Lelyveldian institution of the niggling and absurd Times correction in the light of the Voter News Service election disaster and the Wen Ho Lee debacle.

O RLY

You should go read the rest of that, it is all pretty fantastic.

WEN HO OUCH

In any event, isn't this an amazingly odd venue for Kinsley to so opine? Is the corrections department of the Washington Post so radically different? In some ways it is remarkably worse, as its online corrections page simply lists corrected articles in chronological order-as "bizarre" and "trivial" as they may be.

10 Comments / Post A Comment

theDRA
theDRA (#1,108)

first?

theDRA
theDRA (#1,108)

: I

crotchety
crotchety (#594)

I'd like to know more about this trusting lepidopterist. Are trusting people drawn to lepidoptery or does lepidoptery lead people to drop their natural wariness?

Also, I always thought I was laughing with the Times when I read the corrections. Now I feel kinda bad.

Setec Astrology

At the risk of engaging in the type of behavior that this post is meant to degrade, Renata Adler's book appears to be titled "Canaries in the Mineshaft," not "Canaries in the Coalmine."

Can we get a correction?

Matt
Matt (#26)

DAMNIT.

Matt
Matt (#26)

Ok, not to be a absurd, niggling schoolmarm, but it's 'Canaries in the Mineshaft.' Although maybe this was bait?

Choire Sicha

LOL. Corrected. IT WAS EARLY. I had to do a bunch of housework! Tired! Also fixed.

Also: SEVENTH!11!!!

Matt
Matt (#26)

I hate it when I lose the Internet. I am so bad at the Internet some times.

jolie
jolie (#16)

"Ok, not to be an absurd..."

Fixed that for you. *ducks, runs*

Matt
Matt (#26)

ACK~!!!!! Why am I at work today?

Post a Comment

You must be logged-in to post a comment.

Login To Your Account