Quantcast
 

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

3

Health Care, Here And There

In a post noting a hysterical Investors Business Daily editorial suggesting that "scientist Stephen Hawking wouldn't have a chance in the UK, where the National Health Service would say the life of this brilliant man, because of his physical handicaps, is essentially worthless" (you've spotted the flaw in the logic, yes?), the Spectator's Alex Massie makes an interesting observation about our system of health care vs. Great Britain's.

In Britain you worry what will happen when you fall ill; many Americans worry about what will happen if you fall ill. Will your insurance cover you? Often (but not always), yes it will and the best American care probably is better than the best British care, but there's a greater psychological security to the British system. That's probably worth something too. In other words, many Americans find themselves fretting about healthcare even when they're perfectly healthy. That's a psychological burden people in this country (and many others), don't have to worry about.
Massie correctly suggests that the Democratic health care plan is not actually an attempt to mimic Britain's NHS, but it's still a good point.

3 Comments / Post A Comment

#56
#56 (#56)

538 has a great comparison of the British plan and the Canadian plan with pictures and everything! sigh. http://bit.ly/1qFcX

KarenUhOh
KarenUhOh (#19)

We don't have to deal with this now--please, let's save it till after I've fallen off the actuarial curve of the Earth--but, a simple algorithm involving a population skewing older/feebler, hellbent on collision with cost spiral driven by "market forces," pretty much--ahem--insures, at some not distant juncture, government intervention in the health care system. And not this shallow bedpan shit being talked up now.

Or we could do Natural Selection. If you're into that. God, Darwin, they both run Death Panels of their own.

Still, the silver lining is a declining birth rate, so if you can hold your breath for 40 years, it ought to even out. Of course, medical science'll keep letting you live longer; only it'll cost you.

sigerson
sigerson (#179)

A good friend of mine is a Republican from Mississippi. When he was living in the UK, his wife got pregnant and therefore got free OBGYN care from the NHS. Being a free-market-loving conservative, he went and paid out of his pocket for a private doctor in addition to the NHS.

Long story short -- he and his wife ended up firing the private doctor because the NHS was better.

Post a Comment

You must be logged-in to post a comment.

Login To Your Account